What evidential value does an EasyConstat report have?
EasyConstat produces documented, signed and timestamped private digital evidence. Its weight depends on the technical quality of the package, the context in which it is submitted and the assessment of the court hearing the case.
1. What EasyConstat produces
EasyConstat does not deliver a standalone screenshot. The service creates an evidence package containing the report, the capture, available source data, the HTTP exchange record, the activity log and the digital fingerprints of the principal files.
The report is signed in PAdES-LT format using the electronic seal of PROBANTIA SAS and receives an RFC 3161 timestamp, qualified under eIDAS when that profile is selected. These mechanisms identify the report issuer, make later changes detectable and bind the sealed data to a verifiable time.
2. The legal framework for electronic evidence
Article 1358 of the French Civil Code provides that, except where otherwise provided by law, evidence may be supplied by any means.
Article 1366 of the French Civil Code gives electronic records the same evidential weight as paper records, provided that the person from whom they originate can be duly identified and that they are created and retained in conditions that safeguard their integrity.
Those provisions do not automatically give every electronic file a predetermined evidential weight. The court retains its power of assessment and considers the document’s origin, integrity, collection method, consistency and any challenge raised by the parties.
3. Courts have used EasyConstat reports
Several published decisions show that EasyConstat reports have been submitted in evidence and effectively used by courts when assessing facts documented online.
Paris Judicial Court, 3 July 2024
In an order of 3 July 2024, case no. 24/02473, the court examined an EasyConstat report submitted to establish that online material had been published.
The decision found that the technical rules supporting the reliability of the report had been followed and clearly described. It referred in particular to the equipment, IP address, absence of a proxy, deletion of temporary files, URL, date, time and browsing path. The report was treated as private evidence open to challenge and rebuttal by contrary evidence. In that case, it contributed to establishing the disputed publication.
Paris Court of Appeal, 8 December 2023
In a judgment of 8 December 2023, case no. 21/19696, the Paris Court of Appeal relied in particular on EasyConstat reports produced in July 2017, together with the other evidence, when establishing the exploitation of software and finding acts of infringement. The appeal against that judgment was dismissed by the French Court of Cassation on 3 September 2025.
Paris Court of Appeal, 7 June 2024
In a judgment of 7 June 2024, case no. 23/02874, the court referred to the finding that EasyConstat reports dated 1 December 2022 established the removal of comparative tables previously published online.
4. Difference from a French judicial officer’s statement
A French judicial officer is a public and ministerial officer. Their statement records facts they personally observed and benefits from the evidential regime that the law attaches to their intervention.
EasyConstat is a technical process operated by a private company. It automates and documents digital acquisition, but does not claim public-officer status, the creation of an authentic instrument or legal equivalence with a judicial officer’s statement.
5. Why the package is more robust than a standalone screenshot
- the environment and connection used are described;
- preparation and browsing operations are recorded;
- collected items are bound to the report by SHA-256 fingerprints;
- the signature makes later changes to the report detectable;
- the timestamp binds the sealed data to a verifiable time;
- the package can undergo technical verification and adversarial review.
These safeguards strengthen traceability and integrity. By themselves, they do not certify the truth of a statement displayed online, the real identity of its author or the lawfulness of its publication.
6. When to seek legal advice
For high-stakes cases, collection that may interfere with rights, authenticated pages, identity issues or litigation strategy, legal advice should be sought from a lawyer or the relevant judicial officer before acting.
The appropriate evidence method depends on the dispute, the likely degree of challenge, urgency and the other available material.